The term “patriotic investing” is unlikely to leave many people indifferent. That is precisely why Onno Steenbeek (Managing Director Strategic Portfolio Advice) chose it as the title of the inaugural lecture he delivered on Friday to mark his appointment as Professor of Institutional Investment Management at Tilburg University. We spoke with him about what exactly he means by the term and about his plans for the chair, which is made possible by APG Asset Management.
In brief
• The best way to mobilize capital in the national interest is to create an investment opportunity that does not need patriotism to be attractive.
• The investment window, co-developed by Steenbeek, provides a common language that helps governments and institutional investors engage in dialogue.
• Through his chair, he plans to conduct research into areas including the application of the investment window and participants’ support for certain types of investments.
In the run-up to his inaugural lecture, Steenbeek asked invited guests what they associated with patriotic investing. Their answers ranged from sovereignty and resilience to investing in the Netherlands. A sizable group, however, finds the term uncomfortable and believes pension funds should focus primarily on achieving good returns.
What do you mean by patriotic investing?
“I chose the term to be a little provocative and even slightly irritating, and it worked. For me, the point is that investing in the Netherlands and Europe is currently high on many agendas simply because it concerns the Netherlands or Europe. That is different from impact investing, where the social impact comes first, or investing for strategic autonomy, where the focus is on resilience.
Two developments are taking place at the same time. On the one hand, there is the debate about strategic autonomy and dependence on the United States in particular. On the other, there is enormous demand for capital for areas such as infrastructure and economic growth, while governments cannot finance all of this themselves. As a result, they are increasingly looking to pension funds.
My original argument grew out of research for the World Bank on pension funds that are required to invest a large share of their assets within their own national borders. The question was whether greater international diversification might actually make more sense, because forcing funds to invest domestically almost always comes at the expense of returns. At the same time, there is growing pressure around the world to invest more pension assets domestically. The debate about sovereignty was added to this later.
That creates a paradox in patriotic investing: the best way to mobilize capital for your country is to develop an investment proposition that does not need patriotism to be attractive. So my conclusion is not that pension funds should invest more in the Netherlands, but that governments and the market should create more Dutch investment propositions in which pension funds can invest responsibly. And in that case, it matters much less whether the investor is ABP or, for example, a Canadian pension fund.”
How does the push to invest more pension assets domestically relate to the need for a well-diversified portfolio?
“If you look at ABP, around 95 percent of its investments were Dutch in the mid-1990s, mainly fixed-income investments. As ABP grew and Dutch government debt became relatively smaller, there was an increasing need to invest more abroad. Academic research tells us that this kind of risk diversification makes a great deal of sense. Diversification is the only free lunch in finance.
You want to avoid a situation in which both people’s income and their pensions are hit by the same shock. A corporate pension fund, for example, is only allowed to invest a limited amount in its sponsoring company. That prevents employees from losing not only their jobs but also a large part of their pensions if the company goes bankrupt. The U.S. energy company Enron was a dramatic example of that.
During my research for the World Bank, I also looked at the island nation of Grenada, for example. Virtually all of its pension assets were invested in its own economy until a hurricane passed very close to the island. They realized they could have lost almost everything if the hurricane’s path had been just slightly different. After that, they decided to diversify their portfolio much more internationally. That is a very clear example of why diversification is, and remains, so important.”
To bring the interests of governments and pension funds closer together, you developed the investable window together with Sebastien Betermier of McGill University. How does it work?
“At APG, we are seeing more and more parties approach us with potential investments, including organizations such as Rijkswaterstaat, the Dutch infrastructure and water management agency. What quickly becomes clear is that governments and investors sometimes speak different languages. People at Rijkswaterstaat know everything about dikes, rivers and water management, while investors know a great deal about returns, risks and the other conditions arising from their fiduciary duty.
It is not rocket science, but the investable window has proved useful in helping the parties discuss ways to make a project investable. It looks at four dimensions: return and risk, scale and liquidity, governance and predictability, and development risk. The window is different for every pension fund. And even if an investment fits within the window, it still has to be compared with similar investment opportunities.
Ultimately, investing closer to home comes down to three things: whether you can, whether you may, and whether you will continue to be allowed to. The investable window determines whether you can make an investment. A fund’s mandate determines whether you may make it. And public support determines whether you can continue to do so. The investable window is already being used in practice in discussions about areas such as defense and venture capital, and we also want to apply it to affordable housing.”
What can governments and pension funds expect from each other in this area?
“That we engage in an open dialogue about specific investment propositions and the factors that make it difficult for them to fit within the window. And then, of course, about solutions that could make a proposition suitable for the portfolio. The solution depends on the problem, but a government or an organization such as the National Investment Institution (NII), for example, could take on certain risks. When a highway was being built in Belgium, there were risks that pension funds found difficult to assess. The European Investment Bank (EIB) therefore took a first-loss position: the EIB would absorb any initial losses. This reduced the risk for the remainder of the financing, making pension funds very willing to invest.
Public-private partnerships have of course been around for a long time. My main point is that pension funds and asset managers could take a more creative approach and become involved earlier in the process. The roles must remain clear, however. The government sets societal priorities and decides how public funds are used. The pension investor indicates the conditions under which it can invest responsibly.”
What academic questions do you want to explore through your chair in the coming years?
“One important topic is how we can use the investable window in different sectors to bring parties together. I am also interested in the relationship between culture and institutional investing. How does culture, for example, affect public support for certain investments and people’s willingness to privatize public activities? A third area is support among pension plan participants. How do you build support for things like investing in the Netherlands or sustainable investing when you also show people the potential consequences for their pensions?”
Does the fact that the chair is made possible by APG Asset Management affect your research?
“Without APG Asset Management, this chair would not exist. I will conduct research on topics that are relevant to APG, ABP and the pension sector as a whole. The chair also provides access to other knowledge networks. Research and thought leadership are part of the DNA of APG and ABP. In that sense, it will not fundamentally change the way I work: I have conducted this kind of research before at Erasmus University.”